"Expect seven misfortunes from the cripple, and
forty-two from the one-eyed man; but when the hunchback
comes, say 'Allah our aid.'"
ARAB PROVERB
INQUIRY. Let us inquire in the first place: What is
Scepticism? The word means looking, questioning,
investigating. One must pass by contemptuously the
Christian liar's gloss which interprets
"sceptic" as "mocker"; though in a
sense it is true for him, since to inquire into
Christianity is assuredly to mock at it; but I am
concerned to intensify the etymological connotation in
several respects. First, I do not regard mere incredulity
as necessary to the idea, though credulity is
incompatible with it. Incredulity implies a prejudice in
favour of a negative conclusion; and the true sceptic
should be perfectly unbiassed.
Second, I exclude "vital scepticism." What's
the good of anyfink? expects (as we used to learn about
"nonne?") the answer, "Why nuffink!"
and again is prejudiced. Indolence is no virtue in a
questioner. Eagerness, intentness, concentration,
vigilance --- all these I include in the connotation of
"sceptic." Such questioning as has been called
"vital scepticism" is but a device to avoid
true questioning, and therefore its very antithesis, the
devil disguised as an angel of light.
[Or "vice versƒ", friend, if you are a
Satanist; 'tis a matter of words --- words --- words. You
may write "x" for "y" in your
equations, so long as you consistently write
"y" for "x". They remain unchanged
--- and unsolved. Is not all our "knowledge" an
example of this fallacy of writing one unknown for
another, and then crowing like Peter's cock?]
I picture the true sceptic as a man eager and alert,
his deep eyes glittering like sharp swords, his hands
tense with effort as he asks, "What does it
matter?"
I picture the false sceptic as a dude or popinjay,
yawning, with dull eyes, his muscles limp, his purpose in
asking the question but the expression of his slackness
and stupidity.
This true sceptic is indeed the man of science; as
Wells' "Moreau" tells us. He has devised some
means of answering his first question, and its answer is
another question. It is difficult to conceive of any
question, indeed, whose answer does not imply a thousand
further questions. So simple an inquiry as "Why is
sugar sweet?" involves an infinity of chemical
researches, each leading ultimately to the blank wall ---
what is matter? and an infinity of physiological
researches, each (similarly) leading to the blank wall
--- what is mind?
Even so, the relation between the two ideas is
unthinkable; causality is itself unthinkable; it depends,
for one thing, upon experience --- and what, in God's
name, is experience? Experience is impossible without
memory. What is memory? The mortar of the temple of the
ego, whose bricks are the impressions. And the ego? The
sum of our experience, may be. (I doubt it!) Anyhow, we
have got values of "y" and "z" for
"x", and the values of "x" and
"z" for "y" --- all our equations are
indeterminate; all our knowledge is relative, even in a
narrower sense than is usually implied by the statement.
Under the whip of the clown God, our performing donkeys
the philosophers and men of science run round and round
in the ring; they have amusing tricks: they are cleverly
trained; but they get nowhere.
I don't seem to be getting anywhere myself.
A fresh attempt. Let us look into the simplest and
most certain of all possible statements. "Thought
exists", or if you will, "Cogitatur".
Descartes supposed himself to have touched bed-rock
with his "Cogito," "ergo Sum."
Huxley pointed out the complex nature of this
proposition, and that it was an enthymeme with the
premiss "Omnes sunt, qui cogitant" suppressed.
He reduced it to "Cogito;" or, to avoid the
assumption of an ego, "Cogitatur."
Examining more closely this statement, we may still
cavil at its form. We cannot translate it into English
without the use of the verb to be, so, that, after all,
existence is implied. Nor do we readily conceive that
contemptuous silence is sufficient answer of the further
query, "By whom is it thought?" The Buddhist
may find it easy to image an act without an agent; I am
not so clever. It may be possible for a sane man; but I
should like to know more about his mind before I gave a
final opinion.
But apart from purely formal objections, we may still
inquire: Is this "Cogitatur" true?
Yes; reply the sages; for to deny it implies thought;
"Negatur" is only a sub-section of
"Cogitatur".
This involves, however, an axiom that the part is of
the same nature as the whole; or (at the very least) an
axiom that "A" is "A".
Now, I do not wish to deny that "A" is
"A", or may occasionally be "A". But
certainly "A is A" is a very different
statement to our original "Cogitatur".
The proof of "Cogitatur", in short, rests
not upon itself but upon the validity of our logic; and
if by logic we mean (as we should mean) the Code of the
Laws of Thought, the irritating sceptic will have many
more remarks to make: for it now appears that the proof
that "thought exists" depends upon the truth of
that which is thought, to say no more.
We have taken "Cogitatur", to try and avoid
the use of "esse;" but "A is A"
involves that very idea, and the proof is fatally flawed.
"Cogitatur" depends on "Est;" and
there's no avoiding it.
Shall we get on any better if we investigate this
"Est" --- Something is --- Existence is ---
אהיה אשר ;אהיה [Heh-Yod-Heh-Aleph Resh-Shin-Aleph Heh-Yod-Heh-Aleph] ?
What is Existence? The question is so fundamental that
it finds no answer. The most profound meditation only
leads to an exasperating sense of impotence. There is, it
seems, no simple rational idea in the mind which
corresponds to the word.
It is easy of course to drown the question in
definitions, leading us to further complexity --- but
"Existence is the gift of Divine
Providence,"
"Existence is the opposite of
Non-Existence,"
do not help us much!
The plain "Existence is Existence" of the
Hebrews goes farther. It is the most sceptical of
statements, in spite of its form. Existence is just
existence, and there's no more to be said about it; don't
worry! Ah, but there is more to be said about it! Though
we search ourselves for a thought to match the word, and
fail, yet we have Berkeley's perfectly convincing
argument that (so far as we know it) existence must mean
"thinking existence" or "spiritual
existence".
Here then we find our "Est" to imply
"Cogitatur;" and Berkeley's arguments are
"irrefragable, yet fail to produce conviction"
(Hume) because the "Cogitatur;" as we have
shown, implies "Est".
Neither of these ideas is simple; each involves the
other. Is the division between them in our brain a proof
of the total incapacity of that organ, or is there some
flaw in our logic? For all depends upon our logic; not
upon the simple identity "A is A" only, but
upon its whole structure from the question of simple
propositions, enormously difficult from the moment when
it occurred to the detestable genius that invented
"existential import" to consider the matter, to
that further complexity and contradiction, the syllogism.
"Thought is" appears then (in the worst case
possible, denial) as the conclusion of the premisses:
There is denial of thought.
(All) Denial of thought is thought.
Even formally, 'tis a clumsy monster. Essentially, it
seems to involve a great deal beyond our original
statement. We compass heaven and earth to make one
syllogism; and when we have made it, it is tenfold more
the child of mystery than ourselves.
We cannot here discuss the whole problem of the
validity (the surface- question of the logical validity)
of the syllogism; though one may throw out the hint that
the doctrine of distributed middle seems to assume a
knowledge of a Calculus of Infinites which is certainly
beyond my own poor attainments, and hardly impregnable to
the simple reflection that all mathematics is
conventional, and not essential; relative, and not
absolute.
We go deeper and deeper, then, it seems, from the One
into the Many. Our primary proposition depends no longer
upon itself, but upon the whole complex being of man,
poor, disputing, muddle-headed man! Man with all his
limitations and ignorance; man --- man!
We are of course no happier when we examine the Many,
separately or together. They converge and diverge, each
fresh hill-toÿ of knowledge disclosing a vast land
unexplored; each gain of power in our telescopes opening
out new galaxies; each improvement in our microscoÿes
showing us life minuter and more incomprehensible. A
mystery of the mighty spaces between molecules; a mystery
of the ether-cushions that fend off the stars from
collision! A mystery of the fulness of things; a mystery
of the emptiness of things! Yet, as we go, there grows a
sense, an instinct, a premonition --- what shall I call
it? --- that Being is One, and Thought is One, and Law is
One --- until we ask What is that One?
Then again we spin words --- words --- words. And we
have got no single question answered in any ultimate
sense.
What is the moon made of?
Science replies "Green Cheese."
For our one moon we have now two ideas:
"Greenness," and "Cheese."
"Greenness" depends on the sunlight, and the
eye, and a thousand other things.
"Cheese" depends on bacteria and
fermentation and the nature of the cow.
"Deeper, even deeper, into the mire of
things!"
Shall we cut the Gordian knot? shall we say
"There is God"?
What, in the devil's name, is God?
If (with Moses) we picture Him as an old man showing
us His back parts, who shall blame us? The great Question
--- "any" question is the great question ---
does indeed treat us thus cavalierly, the disenchanted
Sceptic is too prone to think!
Well, shall we define Him as a loving Father, as a
jealous priest, as a gleam of light upon the holy Ark?
What does it matter? All these images are of wood and
stone, the wood and stone of our own stupid brains! The
Fatherhood of God is but a human type; the idea of a
human father conjoined with the idea of immensity. Two
for One again!
No combination of thoughts can be greater than the
thinking brain itself; all we can think of God or say of
Him, so long as our words really represent thoughts, is
less than the whole brain which thinks, and orders
speech.
Very good; shall we proceed by denying Him all
thinkable qualities, as do the heathen? All we obtain is
mere negation of thought.
Either He is unknowable, or He is less than we are.
Then, too, that which is unknowable is unknown; and
"God" or "There is God" as an answer
to our question becomes as meaningless as any other.
Who are we, then?
We are Spencerian Agnostics, poor silly, damned
Spencerian Agnostics!
And there is an end of the matter.
It is surely time that we began to question the
validity of some of our data. So far our scepticism has
not only knocked to pieces our tower of thought, but
rooted up the foundation-stone and ground it into finer
and more poisonous powder than that into which Moses
ground the calf. These golden Elohim! Our calf-heads that
brought us not out of Egypt, but into a darkness deeper
and more tangible than any darkness of the double Empire
of Asar.
Hume put his little ? to Berkeley's God-!; Buddha his
? to the Vedic Atman-! --- and neither Hume nor Buddha
was baulked of his reward. Ourselves may put ? to our own
? since we have found no ! to put it to; and wouldn't it
be jolly if our own second ? suddenly straightened its
back and threw its chest out and marched off as !?
Suppose then we accept our scepticism as having
destroyed our knowledge root and branch --- is there no
limit to its action? Does it not in a sense stultify
itself? Having destroyed logic by logic --- if Satan cast
out Satan, how shall his kingdom stand?
Let us stand on the Mount, Saviours of the World that
we are, and answer "Get thee behind me Satan!"
though refraining from quoting texts or giving reasons.
Oho! says somebody; is Aleister Crowley here? ---
Samson blinded and bound, grinding corn for the
Philistines!
Not at all, dear boy!
We shall put all the questions that we can put --- but
we may find a tower built upon a rock, against which the
winds beat in vain.
Not what Christians call faith, be sure! But what
(possibly) the forgers of the Epistles --- those eminent
mystics! --- meant by faith. What I call Samadhi --- and
as "faith without works is dead," so, good
friends, Samadhi is all humbug unless the practitioner
shows the glint of its gold in his work in the world. If
your mystic becomes Dante, well; if Tennyson, a fig for
his trances!
But how does this tower of Samadhi stand the assault
of Question-time?
Is not the idea of Samadhi just as dependent on all
the other ideas --- man, time, being, thought, logic? If
I seek to explain Samadhi by analogy, am I not often
found talking as if we knew all about Evolution, and
Mathematics, and History? Complex and unscientific
studies, mere straws before the blast of our hunchback
friend!
Well, one of the buttresses is just the small matter
of common sense.
The other day I was with Dorothy, and, as I foolishly
imagined, very cosy: for her sandwiches are celebrated.
It was surely bad taste on the part of Father Bernard
Vaughan, and Dr. Torrey, and Ananda Metteyya, and Mr. G.
W. Foote, and Captain Fuller, and the ghost of Immanuel
Kant, and Mr. Bernard Shaw, and young Neuburg, to
intrude. But intrude they did; and talk! I never heard
anything like it. Every one with his own point of view;
but all agreed that Dorothy was non-existent, or if
existent, a most awful specimen, that her buns were
stale, and her tea stewed; "ergo," that I was
having a very poor time of it. Talk! Good God! But
Dorothy kept on quietly and took no notice; and in the
end I forgot about them.
Thinking it over soberly, I see now that very likely
they were quite right: I can't prove it either way. But
as a mere practical man, I intend taking the steamer ---
for my sins I am in Gibraltar --- back to Dorothy at the
earliest possible moment. Sandwiches of bun and German
sausage may be vulgar and even imaginary --- it's the
taste I like. And the more I munch, the more complacent I
feel, until I go so far as to offer my critics a bite.
This sounds in a way like the "Interior
Certainly" of the common or garden Christian; but
there are differences.
The Christian insists on notorious lies being accepted
as an essential part of his (more usually her) system; I,
on the contrary, ask for facts, for observation. Under
Scepticism, true, one is just as much a house of cards as
the other; but only in the philosophical sense.
Practically, Science is true; and Faith is foolish.
Practically, 3 x 1 = 3 is the truth; and 3 x 1 = 1 is
a lie; though, sceptically, both statements may be false
or unintelligible.
Practically, Franklin's method of obtaining fire from
heaven is better than that of Prometheus or Elijah. I am
now writing by the light that Franklin's discovery
enabled men to use.
Practically, "I concentrated my mind upon a white
radiant triangle in whose centre was a shining eye, for
22 minutes and 10 seconds, my attention wandering 45
times" is a scientific and valuable statement.
"I prayed fervently to the Lord for the space of
many days" means anything or nothing. Anybody who
cares to do so may imitate my experiment and compare his
result with mine. In the latter case one would always be
wondering what "fervently" meant and who
"the Lord" was, and how many days made
"many."
My claim, too, is more modest than the Christian's. He
(usually she) knows more about my future than is
altogether pleasant; I claim nothing absolute from my
Samadhi --- I know only too well the worthlessness of
single-handed observations, even on so simple a matter as
a boiling- point determination! --- and as for his
(usually her) future, I content myself with mere common
sense about the probable end of a fool.
So that after all I keep my scepticism intact - and I
keep my Samadhi intact. The one balances the other; I
care nothing for the vulgar brawling of these two varlets
of my mind!
If, however, you would really like to know what might
be said on the soldierly side of the question, I shall
endeavour to oblige.
It is necessary if a question is to be intelligibly
put that the querent should be on the same plane as the
quesited.
Answer is impossible if you ask: Are round squares
triangular? or Is butter virtuous? or How many ounces go
to the shilling? for the "questions" are not
really questions at all.
So if you ask me Is Samadhi real? I reply: First, I
pray you, establish a connection between the terms. What
do you mean by Samadhi?
There is a physiological (or pathological; never mind
now!) state which I call Samadhi; and that state is as
real - in relation to man - as sleep, or intoxication, or
death.
Philosophically, we may doubt the existence of all of
these; but we have no grounds for discriminating between
them - the Academic Scepticism is a wholesale firm, I
hope! - and practically, I challenge you to draw valid
distinctions.
All these are states of the consciousness of man; and
if you seek to destroy one, all fall together.
I must, at the risk of appearing to digress, insist
upon this distinction between philosophical and practical
points of view, or (in Qabalistic language) between
Kether and Malkuth.
In private conversation I find it hard - almost
impossible - to get peoÿle to understand what seems to me
so very simple a point. I shall try to make it
exceptionally clear.
A boot is an Illusion.
A hat is an illusion.
"Therefore," a boot is a hat.
So argue my friends, not distributing the middle term.
But this argue I.
"Therefore" (though it is not a syllogism),
all boots and hats are illusions.
I add:
To the man in Kether no illusions matter.
"Therefore:" To the man in Kether neither
boots nor hats matter.
In fact, the man in Kether is out of all relation to
these boots and hats.
You, they say, claim to be a man in Kether (I don't).
Why then, do you not wear boots on your head and hats on
your feet?
I can only answer that I the man in Kether ('tis but
an argument) am out of all relation as much with feet and
heads as with boots and hats. But why should I (from my
exalted pinnacle) stoop down and worry the headed and
footed gentleman in Malkuth, who after all doesn't exist
for me, by these drastic alterations in his toilet? There
is no distinction whatever; I might easily put the boots
on his shoulders, with his head on one foot and the hat
on the other.
In short, why not be a clean-living Irish gentleman,
even if you do have insane ideas about the universe?
Very good, say my friends, unabashed, then why not
stick to that? Why glorify Spanish gipsies when you have
married a clergyman's daughter?
Why go about proclaiming that you can get as good fun
for eighteenpence as usually costs men a career?
Ah! let me introduce you to the man in Tiphereth; that
is, the man who is trying to raise his consciousness from
Malkuth to Kether.
This Tiphereth man is in a devil of a hole! He knows
theoretically all about the Kether point of view (or
thinks he does) and practically all about the Malkuth
point of view. Consequently he goes about contradicting
Malkuth; he refuses to allow Malkuth to obsess his
thought. He keeps on crying out that there is no
difference between a goat and a God, in the hope of
hypnotising himself (as it were) into that perception of
their identity, which is his (partial and incorrect) idea
of how things look from Kether.
This man performs great magic; very strong medicine.
He does really find gold on the midden and skeletons in
pretty girls.
In Abiegnus the Sacred Mountain of the Rosicrucians
the Postulant finds but a coffin in the central shrine;
yet that coffin contains Christian Rosencreutz who is
dead and is alive for evermore and hath the keys of Hell
and of Death.
Ay! your Tiphereth man, child of Mercy and Justice,
looks deeper than the skin!
But he seems a ridiculous object enough both to the
Malkuth man and to the Kether man.
Still, he's the most interesting man there is; and we
all must pass through that stage before we get our heads
really clear, the Kether-vision above the Clouds that
encircle the mountain Abiegnus.
Running and returning, like the Cherubim, we may now
resume our attempt to drill our hunchback friend into a
presentable soldier. The digression will not have been
all digression, either; for it will have thrown a deal of
light on the question of the limitations of scepticism.
We have questioned the Malkuth point of view; it
appears absurd, be it agreed. But the Tiphereth position
is unshaken; Tiphereth needs no telling that Malkuth is
absurd. When we turn our artillery against Tiphereth,
that too crumbles; but Kether frowns above us.
Attack Kether, and it falls; but the Yetziratic
Malkuth is still there .... until we reach Kether of
Atziluth and the Infinite Light, and Space, and Nothing.
So then we retire up the path, fighting rear-guard
actions; at every moment a soldier is slain by a
hunchback; but as we retire there is always a soldier
just by us.
Until the end. The end? Buddha thought the supply of
hunchbacks infinite; but why should not the soldiers
themselves be infinite in number?
However that may be, here is the point; it takes a
moment for a hunchback to kill his man, and the farther
we get from our base the longer it takes. You may crumble
to ashes the dream-world of a boy, as it were, between
your fingers; but before you can bring the physical
universe tumbling about a man's ears he requires to drill
his hunchbacks so devilish well that they are terribly
like soldiers themselves. And a question capable of
shaking the consciousness of Samadhi could, I imagine,
give long odds to one of Frederick's grenadiers.
It is useless to attack the mystic by asking him if he
is quite sure Samadhi is good for his poor health; 'tis
like asking the huntsman to be very careful, please, not
to hurt the fox.
The ultimate Question, the one that really knocks
Samadhi to pieces, is such a stupendous Idea that it is
far more of a ! than all previous !'s whatever, for all
its ? form.
And the name of that Question is Nibbana.
Take this matter of the soul.
When Mr. Judas McCabbage asks the Man in the Street
why he believes in a soul, the Man stammers out that he
has always heard so; naturally McCabbage has no
difficulty in proving to him by biological methods that
he has no soul; and with a sunny smile each passes on his
way.
But McCabbage is wasted on the philosopher whose
belief in a soul rests on introspection; we must have
heavier metal; Hume will serve our turn, may be.
But Hume in his turn becomes perfectly futile, pitted
against the Hindu mystic, who is in constant intense
enjoyment of his new-found Atman. It takes a Buddha-gun
to knock "his" castle down.
Now the ideas of McCabbage are banal and dull; those
of Hume are live and virile; there is a joy in them
greater than the joy of the Man in the Street. So too the
Buddha-thought, Anatta, is a more splendid conception
than the philosopher's Dutch-doll-like Ego, or the
rational artillery of Hume.
This weapon, too, that has destroyed our lesser, our
illusionary universes, ever revealing one more real,
shall we not wield it with divine ecstasy? Shall we not,
too, perceive the inter-dependence of the Questions and
the Answers, the necessary connection of the one with the
other, so that (just as 0 x ì is an indefinite) we
destroy the absolutism of either ? or ! by their
alternation and balance, until in our series ? ! ? ! ? !
? ... ! ? ! ? ... we care nothing as to which may prove
the final term, any single term being so negligible a
quantity in relation to the vastness of the series? Is it
not a series of geometrical progression, with a factor
positive and incalculably vast?
In the light of the whole process, then, we perceive
that there is no absolute value in the swing of the
pendulum, thought its shaft lengthen, its rate grow
slower, and its sweep wider at every swing.
What should interest us is the consideration of the
Point from which it hangs, motionless at the height of
things! We are unfavourably placed to observe this,
desperately clinging as we are to the bob of the
pendulum, sick with our senseless swinging to and fro in
the abyss!
We must climb up the shaft to reach that point --- but
--- wait one moment! How obscure and subtle has our
simile become! Can we attach any true meaning to the
phrase? I doubt it, seeing what we have taken for the
limits of the swing. True, it may be that at the end the
swing is always 360ø so that the !-point and the ?-point
coincide; but that is not the same thing as having no
swing at all, unless we make kinematics identical with
statics.
What is to be done? How shall such mysteries be
uttered?
Is this how it is that the true Path of the Wise is
said to lie in a totally different plane from all his
advance in the path of Knowledge, and of Trance? We have
already been obliged to take the Fourth Dimension to
illustrate (if not explain) the nature of Samadhi.
Ah, say the adepts, Samadhi is not the end , but the
beginning. You must regard Samadhi as the normal state of
mind which enables you to begin your researches, just as
waking is the state from which you rise to Samadhi, sleep
the state from which you rose to waking. And only from
Sammasamadhi --- continuous trance of the right kind ---
can you rise up as it were on tiptoe and peer through the
clouds unto the mountains.
Now of course it is really awfully decent of the
adepts to take all that trouble over us, and to put it so
nicely and clearly. All we have to do, you see, is to
acquire Sammasamadhi, and then rise on tiptoe. Just so!
But there there are the other adepts. Hard at him!
Little brother, he says, let us rather consider that as
the pendulum swings more and more slowly every time, it
must ultimately stop, as soon as the shaft is of infinite
length. Good! then it isn't a pendulum at all but a
Mahalingam --- The Mahalingam of Shiva ("Namo
Shivaya namaha Aum!") which is all I ever thought it
was; all you have to do is to keep swinging hard --- I
know it's hook-swinging! --- and you get there in the
End. Why trouble to swing? First, because you are bound
to swing, whether you like it or not; second, because
your attention is thereby distracted from those lumbar
muscles in which the hook is so very firmly fixed; third,
because after all it's a ripping good game; fourth,
because you want to get on, and even to seem to progress
is better than standing still. A treadmill is admittedly
good exercise.
True, the question, "Why become an Aarhat?"
should precede, "How become an Arahat?" but an
unbiassed man will easily cancel the first question with
"Why not?" --- the How is not so easy to get
rid of. Then, from the standpoint of the Arahat himself,
perhaps this "Why did I become an Arahat?" and
"How did I become an Arahat?" have but a single
solution!
In any case, we are wasting our time --- we are as
ridiculous with our Arahats as Herod the Tetrarch with
his peacocks! We pose Life with the question Why? and the
first answer is: To obtain the Knowledge and Conversation
of the Holy Guardian Angel.
To attach meaning to this statement we must obtain
that Knowledge and Conversation: and when we have done
that, we may proceed to the next Question. It is no good
asking it now.
"There are purse-proud, penniless ones who stand
at the door of the tavern, and revile the guests."
We attach little importance to the Reverend
Out-at-Elbows, thundering in Bareboards Chapel that the
rich man gets no enjoyment from his wealth.
Good, then. Let us obtain the volume entitled
"The Book of the Sacred Magick of Abramelin the
Mage"; or the magical writings of that holy
illuminated Man of God, Captain Fuller, and carry out
fully their instructions.
And only when we have succeeded, when we have put a
colossal ! against our vital ? need we inquire whether
after all the soldier is not going to develoÿ spinal
curvature.
Let us take the first step; let us sing:
"I do not ask to see
The distant path; one step's enough for me."
But (you will doubtless say) I pith your ? itself with
another ?: Why question life at all? Why not remain
"a clean-living Irish gentleman" content with
his handicap, and contemptuous of card and pencil? Is not
the Buddha's goad "Everything is sorrow" little
better than a currish whine? What do I care for old age,
disease, and death? I'm a man, and a Celt at that. I spit
on your snivelling Hindu prince, emasculate with
debauchery in the first place, and asceticism in the
second. A weak, dirty, paltry cur, sir, your Gautama!
Yes, I think I have no answer to that. The sudden
apprehension of some vital catastrophe may have been the
exciting cause of my conscious devotion to the attainment
of Adeptship --- but surely the capacity was there,
inborn. Mere despair and desire can do little; anyway,
the first impulse of fear was the passing spasm of an
hour; the magnetism of the path itself was the true lure.
It is as foolish to ask me "Why do you adep?"
as to ask God "Why do you pardon?" "C'est
son métier."
I am not so foolish as to think that my doctrine can
ever gain the ear of the world. I expect that ten
centuries hence the "nominal Crowleians" will
be as pestilent and numerous a body as the "nominal
Christians" are to-day; for (at present) I have been
able to devise no mechanism for excluding them. Rather,
perhaps, should I seek to find them a niche in the
shrine, just as Hinduism provides alike for those capable
of the Upanishads and those whose intelligence hardly
reaches to the Tantras. In short, one must abandon the
reality of religion for a sham, so that the religion may
be universal enough for those few who are capable of its
reality to nestle to its breast, and nurse their nature
on its starry milk. But we anticipate!
My message is then twofold; to the greasy
"bourgeois" I preach discontent; I shock him, I
stagger him, I cut away earth from under his feet, I turn
him upside down, I give him hashish and make him run
amok, I twitch his buttocks with the red-hot tongs of my
Sadistic fancy -- until he feels uncomfortable.
But to the man who is already as uneasy as St.
Lawrence on his silver grill, who feels the spirit stir
in him, even as a woman feels, and sickens at, the first
leap of the babe in her womb, to him I bring the splendid
vision, the perfume and the glory, the Knowledge and
Conversation of the Holy Guardian Angel. And to whosoever
hath attained that height will I put a further Question,
announce a further Glory.
It is my misfortune and not my fault that I am bound
to deliver this elementary Message.
"Man has two sides; one to face the world
with, One to show a woman when he loves
her."
We must pardon Browning his bawdy jest; for his truth
is ower true! But it is your own fault if you are the
world instead of the beloved; and only see of me what
Moses saw of God!
It is disgusting to have to spend one's life jetting
dirt in the face of the British public in the hope that
in washing it they may wash off the acrid grease of their
commercialism, the saline streaks of their hypocritical
tears, the putrid perspiration of their morality, the
dribbling slobber of their sentimentality and their
religion. And they don't wash it! ...
But let us take a less unpleasing metaphor, the whip!
As some schoolboy poet repeatedly wrote, his rimes as
poor as Edwin Arnold, his metre as erratic and as good as
Francis Thompson, his good sense and frank indecency a
match for Browning!
"Can't be helped; must be done --- So
..."
Nay! 'tis a bad, bad rime.
And only after the scourge that smites shall come the
rod that consoles, if I may borrow a somewhat daring
simile from Abdullah Haji of Shiraz and the twenty-third
Psalm.
Well, I would much prefer to spend my life at the rod;
it is wearisome and loathsome to be constantly flogging
the tough hide of Britons, whom after all I love.
"Whom the Lord loveth He chasteneth, and scourgeth
every son that He receiveth." I shall really be glad
if a few of you will get it over, and come and sit on
daddy's knee!
The first step is the hardest; make a start, and I
will soon set the hunchback lion and the soldier unicorn
fighting for your crown. And they shall lie down together
at the end, equally glad, equally weary; while sole and
sublime that crown of thine (brother!) shall glitter in
the frosty Void of the abyss, its twelve stars filling
that silence and solitude with a music and a motion that
are more silent and more still than they; thou shalt sit
throned on the Invisible, thine eyes fixed upon That
which we call Nothing, because it is beyond Everything
attainable by thought, or trance, thy right hand gripping
the azure rod of Light, thy left hand clasped upon the
scarlet scourge of Death; thy body girdled with a snake
more brilliant than the sun, its name Eternity; thy mouth
curved moonlike in a smile, in the invisible kiss of
Nuit, our Lady of the Starry Abodes; thy body's electric
flesh stilled by sheer might to a movement closed upon
itself in the controlled fury of Her love --- nay, beyond
all these Images art thou (little brother!) who art
passed from I and Thou, and He unto That which hath no
Name, no Image. ...
Little brother, give me thy hand; for the first step
is hard.
ALEISTER CROWLEY.