In a novel titled The Man Who Was Thursday, G. K. Chesterton
describes a brigade of political police whose specialty was poetry. A
crime is forestalled because a policeman understands the meaning of a
sonnet. There is a great deal of truth behind Chesterton's
whimsicalities. Trends of thought which escape the notice of the
trained observer; writings and works which the sociologist pays scant
attention, together with social phenomena that he considers too
insignificant or too 'odd' to worry about, are sometimes a surer
indication of events to come than the facts that are there for all to
see.
In 1896, an English author, M. P. Shiel, published a short
story in which we read of a band of monstrous criminals ravaging Europe,
slaughtering families which they considered inferior and impending the
progress of humanity, and burning their corpses. The story was
entitled: The S.S.
The atmosphere of terror under the
Nazis, which nobody could forsee, was heralded in the horrible stories
of the German writer Hans Heinz Ewers: The Mandragore and In Terror,
who was destined to become the regime's official poet. Goethe said:
"Coming events cast their shadows before", and it may well be that these
undercurrents in which the future is reflected may be detected and
interpreted, not in events which attract general attention, but in works
and human activities which have nothing to do and are far removed from
what we call 'the stream of history'.
Germany, when National
Socialism first made its appearance, was the home of the exact
sciences. German methods, German logic, and the strictness and
integrity of German scientists were universally esteemed. And yet it
was in a society of this kind that an incoherent and patently crazy
doctrine was introduced and spread like wildfire, starting from quite
insignificant premisses. In the country of Einstein and Planck there
was talk of an 'Aryan physique'; in the homeland of Humboldt and Haeckel
'racial problems' began to be discussed seriously. Such phenomena
cannot be explained as being due solely to economic inflation. There
was something else at work here, a type of madness forseen in the poems
and writings of a neglected few poets and authors.
"Love," said
Jacques Chardonne, "is much more than love." We have to wonder if
history is also often much more than history. In his analysis of the
book Hitler Unmasked by Dr. Otto Dietrich, who was for years the Fuhrer's chief press officer, M. Pierre Cazenave writes as follows:
"...However,
Dr. Dietrich is too easily satisfied with a word he often repeats and
which, in our positivist age, is inadequate to explain Hitler.
'Hitler', he says, 'was a demoniac possessed by nationalist ideas to the
point of madness.' What does he mean by 'demoniac'? And why
'madness'? In the middle ages Hitler would have been described as a man
possessed, but today? Either the word 'demoniac' means nothing, or
else it means possessed by a demon. But what is a demon? Does Dr.
Dietrich believe in the existence of the devil? We must be clear about
this. I, personally, am not satisfied with the word 'demoniac'. Nor
with the word 'madness', which suggests mental disorder...Was Hitler
responsible? In my opinion, yes. And that is why I reject the word
'madness' just as I cannot accept the term 'demoniac'..."
I
totally agree with Cazenave's critique and also find the use of words
such as 'madness' and 'demoniac' wholly unsatisfactory. But it still
leaves us with an unresolved problem. If Hitler was neither mad nor
possessed the history of Nazism would still be inexplicable by the
standards of a 'positivist age'. Psychology in depth has shown that
man's apparently rational actions are in reality governed by forces
which he himself knows nothing, or which are closely linked with a
symbolism having nothing in common with ordinary everyday logic. In the
history of Hitlerism, or rather is certain aspects of this history,
everything happens as if the whole conception on which it was based has
baffled the ordinary historian so that, if we want to understand, we
will have to abandon our positive way of looking at things and enter a
world where reason and reality are no longer valid.
"At bottom",
said Rauschning, "every German has one foot in Atlantis, where he seeks a
better Fatherland and a better patrimony. The double nature of the
Germans, this faculty they have of splitting their personality which
enables them to live in the real world and at the same time to project
themselves into an imaginary world, is especially noticeable in Hitler
and provides the key to his magic socialism."
Rauschning I feel
is certainly on solid footing in his explanation and he is quick to
remind us that this affliction targets not only the Germans:
"whole
nations have fallen into a state of inexplicable agitation. They
follow the flagellants' procession, or are seized by St. Vitus's
Dance...National Socialism is the St. Vitus's Dance of the twentieth
century."
But where does this strange malady come from? To this
question he failed to find a satisfactory answer. "It's deepest roots
are hidden in secret places." It is these secret places that I feel we
ought to explore. And it is not a historian, but a poet, the magician
and the artist who should be our guide. As C.S. Lewis well remarked in
his last book Till We Have Faces, "The gods will not speak to us face to face until we ourselves have a face."
What
madness will we have to descend into to understand Nazism? Quick
examples will suffice. The earth is hollow. We are living inside it.
The stars are blocks of ice. Several moons have already fallen on the
Earth. The whole history of humanity is contained in the struggle
between ice and fire.
Man is not finished. He is on the brink of
formidable mutation which will confer on him the powers the ancients
attributed to the gods. A few specimens of the New Man exist in the
world, who have perhaps come here from beyond the frontiers of time and
space.
Alliances could be formed with the Master of the World or
the King of Fear who reignes over a city hidden somewhere in the East.
Those who conclude a pact will change the surface of the Earth and
window the human adventure with a new meaning for many thousands of
years.
Such were the 'scientific' theories and 'religious'
conceptions on which Nazism was originally based and in which Hitler and
the members of his group believed - theories which have, to a large
extent, dominated social and political trends and shaped recent
history. The fact that such ideas were irrational did not stop them
from spreading and did not stop the true 'believers' from discarding the
solid ground of rigorous investigation.
It is well known that
the Nazi party was openly, and even flamboyantly anti-intellectual; that
it burnt books and relegated the theoretical physicists among it's
'Judeo-Marxist' enemies. Hitler used to say: "We are often abused for
being enemies of the mind and spirit. Well, that is what we are, but in
a far deeper sense than bourgeois science could ever imagine." As
early as 1925 every scientist in Germany and Austria received a letter
and an ultimatum:
"The time has come for you to choose - whether
to be with us or against us. While Hitler is cleaning up politics, Hans
Horbiger will sweep out of the way the bogus sciences. The doctrine of
eternal ice will be a sign of the German people. Beware! Come over to
our side before it is too late."
There was a fury to these
beliefs. Hitler was talking one day to Rauschning, the Governor of
Danzig, about the problem of a mutation of the human race. Rauschning,
not possessing the key to such strange preoccupations, interpreted
Hitler's remarks in terms of a stock-breeder. This did not satisfy
Hitler in the slightest and he screamed at the man: "The new man is
living amongst us now! He is here! Isn't that enough for you? I will
tell you a secret. I have seen the new man. He is intrepid and cruel.
I was afraid of him. "
"In uttering these words," added Rausching, "Hitler was trembling in a kind of ecstasy."
It was Rauschning too who related the following episode:
"A
person close to Hitler told me that he wakes up in the night screaming
and in convulsions. He calls for help, and appears to be half
paralysed. He is seized with a panic that makes him tremble until the
bed shakes. He utters confused and unintelligible sounds, gasping, as
if on the point of suffocation. The same person described to me one of
these fits, with details that I would refuse to believe had I not
complete confidence in my informant...Hitler was standing up in his
room, swaying and looking all round him as if he were lost. 'It's he,
it's he', he groaned; 'he's come for me!' His lips were white; he was
sweating profusely. Suddenly he uttered a string of meaningless
figures, then words and scraps of sentences. It was terrifying. He
used strange expressions strung together in bizarre disorder. Then he
relapsed again into silence, but his lips still continued to move. He
was then given a friction and something to drink. Then suddenly he
screamed: 'There! There! Over in the corner! He is there!' - all the
time stamping with his feet and shouting. To quieten him he was
assured that nothing extraordinary had happened, and finally he
gradually calmed down. After that he slept for a long time and became
normal again..." (Source: Hermann Rauschning: Hitler m'a dit. Ed. Co-operation, Paris, 1939)
It
may be thought that such ridiculous notions and such orgiastic lust for
disaster and such disdain for academia and science are things we have
learned from and will not repeat. I fear such thoughts are utterly
absurd if we merely look at the state of the world today and the sudden
emergence of equally ridiculous ideas and the equal shunning of modern
science and academia. If the internet has taught us something it's that
the absurd can find followers. One need only look at the rise of
conspiracy theories and the cult which has emerged around these since
September 11, 2001. Only a trigger is necessary and the rest will
propel itself.
Not convinced? Find the ideas of a hollow earth,
eternal ice and the King of the World too strange to be acceptable
today? How different really are the ideas of David Icke today who
proposes that there is an elite ruling the earth who are in fact
descendents of a reptilian race? How strange is it really that there is
a virulent anti Semitism embedded in these conspiracy theorists? How
different from the madness of Nazism is it that many of these
'believers' will readily cry out for the gallows to be used on those
they call 'traitors'? Or how different is it that pathetic theories
such 'ancient aliens' - which have been thoroughly debunked and which we
know are connected to ideas of an alien race of men and eventually
evolves into more anti Semitism - find ground in mainstream media such
as the 'History' Channel? The Nazis will always be with us and the
horror of fascism, disguised in whatever form, is always there, keeping
us - as Kafka well noted - "a breath away from the ice age."
